@nickhirst999 ….Cont. Also, contrary to some beliefs Dave sang the lead on most of Dark Side, including Money, Time (with Rick) as well as the more obvious Breath.When you think Dark Side dont you realise (as well as from his other great work for the band like on MORE and all the other albums) JUST HOW great Rick was as a musician,stylistically and innovatively more than technically ? ; the moods and sounds he created were unique to him

The path you tread is narrow
and the drop is sheer and very high
The ravens all are watching
from a vantage point nearby
Apprehension creeping like a tube train up your spine
will the tightrope reach the end, will the final couplet rhyme?
And it’s high time, Cymbaline
Please wake me.
A butterfly with broken wings is falling by your side
the ravens all are closing in there’s nowhere you can hide
Your manager and agent are both busy on the phone
Selling coloured photographs to magazines back home

@kenfig

Sorry for ranting on about this but I’m at the top of the highest rated comments bit and it’s not apparent that I’m having a go at “walruson” who had convinced himself that the film version is sung by Roger Waters which it isn’t. I’m not having a go at kubrick070 who uploaded this vid, but I am agreeing with you, kenfig!

Yes this is David Jon Gilmour singing!

@nickhirst999 Absolutely ; most fans will back you up here as Waters sang lead on very few Floyd tracks, even many of his own ; he sings nothing on MORE at all and his lead vocals are easily distinguishable from Gilmours as on Biding My Time, St Tropez, IF, Grantchester, Set the controls, Free Four and Brain Damage ; totally different voice as David’s is more melodic and sweeter

@xxbabii70v3xx2

Actually, the only difference is the vocal track. The rest is identical and there’s no point reciting my own words to me from 2 years ago from wikipedia which anyone can edit.

@nickhirst999 The recording of ‘”Cymbaline” on the album is different from the one in the movie (the latter version is heard on a record player in a bedroom). The vocals are a different take, as the film version is sung by Roger Waters, while the album version is sung by David Gilmour.

@nickhirst999 The recording of ‘”Cymbaline” on the album is different from the one in the movie (the latter version is heard on a record player in a bedroom). The vocals are a different take, as the film version is sung by Roger Waters, while the album version is sung by David Gilmour.

@nickhirst999 actually, its roger.
sorry to disapoint you, but you can even look it up.
The recording of ‘”Cymbaline” on the album is different from the one in the movie (the latter version is heard on a record player in a bedroom). The vocals are a different take, as the film version is sung by Roger Waters, while the album version is sung by David Gilmour.

Of course it is Gilmour. People here don’t realize that movie sound tracks are normally 1/2 to 1 step too fast, and that’s why it sounds different from the Gilmour we are used to.

hey you this one really great i really like how percussion keyboards voice merge together making it really great

CYmbaline’s a great song… But not this version. Is it really David singing…?

Why did the hell is this another version of the song, they should have played the ALBUM FUCKING version.